It's not very often that a book makes me laugh out loud, but it happened today.
I was reading the first six chapters in Lewis' Mere Christianity as part of an on-line book discussion at Challies Dot Com. (I read it years ago and his writing made a huge impact then so I was glad to pick it back up.) While reading the last chapter and the last paragraph, I thought, "Wow! That's me!" and couldn't help having a good chuckle. I mean, when somebody who doesn't know you, who lived in a different country, who was from a different generation...who's dead for Pete's sake.... (AND is a man at that!) describes you so perfectly, you have to sit up, take notice, and then have a good laugh.
The chapters in this reading were on 'Christian Behavior' and the last chapter was titled 'Christian Marriage.' There's so much great stuff in this chapter, you've got to read it for yourself. But the thing that got me was at the end Lewis, a bachelor at the time, was writing about how in a Christian marriage the man is to be the "head." He answers two questions that people often have in response to this: 1) Why should there be a head at all? and 2) Why should it be the man?
Well, the first question Matt and I answered quite some time ago: somebody's got to steer the ship! (Or paddle the pirogue, in our case.) Mostly, we agree on decisions that have to be made. It may take a lot of (long) discussions (:->), but almost always we end up being on the same page. BUT, when we don't, I've come to the place of understanding that Matt is Biblically the head of our home and it is his responsibility to 'be the man', so to speak. It is my role to submit and support. I actually find a lot of comfort in that. (Trust me, that's taken a good bit of work on God's part....and He's not done yet!)
But question number 2? If someone has to be in charge, why does it have to be the MAN? Well....I hadn't really thought that through. First, Lewis says, it's just natural. He says even other women tsk-tsk at wives who run over their husbands. And almost all women are offended when told that they 'wear the pants' in the marriage. "There must be something unnatural about the rule of wives over husbands, because the wives themselves are half ashamed of it and despise the husbands they rule." I agree with you, C.S.
Secondly, Lewis says this:
"...here I speak quite frankly as a bachelor, because [it is a reason] you can see from outside even better than from inside. The relations of the family to the outer world - what might be called its foreign policy - must depend, in the last resort, upon the man, because he always ought to be, and usually is, much more just to the outsiders. A woman is primarily fighting for her own children and husband against the rest of the world. Naturally, almost, in a sense, rightly, their claims override, for her, all other claims. She is the special trustee of their interests. The function of the husband is to see that this natural preference of hers is not given its head. He has the last word in order to protect other people from the intense family patriotism of the wife. If anyone doubts this, let me ask a simple question. If your dog has bitten the child next door.........which would you sooner have to deal with, the master of that house or the mistress? Or, if you are a married woman, let me ask you this question. Much as you admire your husband, would you not say that his chief failing is his tendency not to stick up for his rights and yours against the neighbours as vigorously as you would like? A bit of an Appeaser?
Ack! That's us, perfectly. Matt is absolutely much more 'just to outsiders' than me. And yes, he's had to 'protect' others from my 'patriotism' and help me keep things in perspective. That, as Martha would say, is a good thing. Sigh.
So - Read Mere Christianity if you haven't. Check out Challies, too. Good stuff.
I love Lewis. I mean really love...his humor...his wisdom...his creativity...There's been a good bit of heated discussion on Lewis at Challies and, well, I just don't get it. In a lot of his writings, Lewis himself says he's just a layperson trying to figure things out just like everyone else. No, his books aren't drenched with Scripture references and exposition. When I want that, I go to Boice or Lloyd-Jones, Piper or Sproul, MacArthur or Tozer, Spurgeon or Calvin.....But when I want to look at life as the story God is writing with all of our lives, I go to Lewis. When I want my heart and head to be opened to the magical mystery of our infinite, awesome God, I find a kindred spirit in Lewis.

I was reading the first six chapters in Lewis' Mere Christianity as part of an on-line book discussion at Challies Dot Com. (I read it years ago and his writing made a huge impact then so I was glad to pick it back up.) While reading the last chapter and the last paragraph, I thought, "Wow! That's me!" and couldn't help having a good chuckle. I mean, when somebody who doesn't know you, who lived in a different country, who was from a different generation...who's dead for Pete's sake.... (AND is a man at that!) describes you so perfectly, you have to sit up, take notice, and then have a good laugh.
The chapters in this reading were on 'Christian Behavior' and the last chapter was titled 'Christian Marriage.' There's so much great stuff in this chapter, you've got to read it for yourself. But the thing that got me was at the end Lewis, a bachelor at the time, was writing about how in a Christian marriage the man is to be the "head." He answers two questions that people often have in response to this: 1) Why should there be a head at all? and 2) Why should it be the man?
Well, the first question Matt and I answered quite some time ago: somebody's got to steer the ship! (Or paddle the pirogue, in our case.) Mostly, we agree on decisions that have to be made. It may take a lot of (long) discussions (:->), but almost always we end up being on the same page. BUT, when we don't, I've come to the place of understanding that Matt is Biblically the head of our home and it is his responsibility to 'be the man', so to speak. It is my role to submit and support. I actually find a lot of comfort in that. (Trust me, that's taken a good bit of work on God's part....and He's not done yet!)
But question number 2? If someone has to be in charge, why does it have to be the MAN? Well....I hadn't really thought that through. First, Lewis says, it's just natural. He says even other women tsk-tsk at wives who run over their husbands. And almost all women are offended when told that they 'wear the pants' in the marriage. "There must be something unnatural about the rule of wives over husbands, because the wives themselves are half ashamed of it and despise the husbands they rule." I agree with you, C.S.
Secondly, Lewis says this:
"...here I speak quite frankly as a bachelor, because [it is a reason] you can see from outside even better than from inside. The relations of the family to the outer world - what might be called its foreign policy - must depend, in the last resort, upon the man, because he always ought to be, and usually is, much more just to the outsiders. A woman is primarily fighting for her own children and husband against the rest of the world. Naturally, almost, in a sense, rightly, their claims override, for her, all other claims. She is the special trustee of their interests. The function of the husband is to see that this natural preference of hers is not given its head. He has the last word in order to protect other people from the intense family patriotism of the wife. If anyone doubts this, let me ask a simple question. If your dog has bitten the child next door.........which would you sooner have to deal with, the master of that house or the mistress? Or, if you are a married woman, let me ask you this question. Much as you admire your husband, would you not say that his chief failing is his tendency not to stick up for his rights and yours against the neighbours as vigorously as you would like? A bit of an Appeaser?
Ack! That's us, perfectly. Matt is absolutely much more 'just to outsiders' than me. And yes, he's had to 'protect' others from my 'patriotism' and help me keep things in perspective. That, as Martha would say, is a good thing. Sigh.
So - Read Mere Christianity if you haven't. Check out Challies, too. Good stuff.
I love Lewis. I mean really love...his humor...his wisdom...his creativity...There's been a good bit of heated discussion on Lewis at Challies and, well, I just don't get it. In a lot of his writings, Lewis himself says he's just a layperson trying to figure things out just like everyone else. No, his books aren't drenched with Scripture references and exposition. When I want that, I go to Boice or Lloyd-Jones, Piper or Sproul, MacArthur or Tozer, Spurgeon or Calvin.....But when I want to look at life as the story God is writing with all of our lives, I go to Lewis. When I want my heart and head to be opened to the magical mystery of our infinite, awesome God, I find a kindred spirit in Lewis.


2 comments:
I agree whole heartedly. I do not understand the controversy. Lewis never said he was a "theologian." Lewis knew people, and he discerned his own heart and others in a way that most theologians don't even attempt to, because they aren't as honest as he was with heart issues. Lewis has showed me more than any other writer. Have you sent my study yet? Lynn
This is my first stop at your blog. I hopped over from Challies, but I've seen your comments on Lynn's site as well. I enjoyed your post. It's funny though, the very thing that struck you, didn't hit me at all. It puzzled me. Apparently not all women are created equal. In my family I'm more an appeaser when it comes to outsiders. It was good to read your take on it.
I'm not that suprised that people have differing opinions about Lewis, particularly in reformed circles, since he was not reformed. I love him and greatly admire him (he reminds me of my husband in a lot of ways); but I disagree with some of what he says and agree with some - like I do with a lot of my brothers and sisters in Christ. As you've said, he has incredible insight into human nature and the Christian life and is an invaluable resource in that regard. He was also, by his own admission, not a theologian, so it should not be a big deal if someone finds fault with his theology. What has surprised me (and my husband) to no end it the heat that discussion of Lewis generates, on both sides. To some he's, like a sacred cow, and to others, well, they can't even regard him as a brother in Christ. This reading group has been an eye-opening experience in a lot of ways.
Post a Comment